Jump to content
Melbourne Football

Round 23: Melbourne City v Brisbane Roar, AAMI Park, Sat 28 March 7.30 pm


Murfy1
 Share

Recommended Posts

 

 

 

As Cat A and B members we can relocate to GA if we want, so the process is not a problem. My problem is I pay extra for my seat and I want to bring friends to experience the same viewing that I do. I'm not happy that the club can't allow us to bring a friend for a discounted price into an unallocated seat in those sections. Instead I have to relocate into GA for the price of a Cat A seat for that game, losing money I paid for my better seat for the sole purpose of bringing them more members to the club. Quite frankly they can go shove it you know where.

Think you're being a little harsh on the club there. If you can "bring a mate" to sit in the Cat A or Cat B seats, then all the others who come along would want to sit there and experience Cat A & B seats. I think we should be greatful the club is allowing us to "bring a mate". Can't satisfy everyone.

I don't think I am at all. As a GA member you can be grateful. As a Cat A Im not.

Niko is making a valid point. MrsJW and I are also Premium A, and not qualifying for any concession we pay a fair bit for our reserved seats. Yes, of course it is our choice to do that. and MHFC is under no obligation to do anything more than it does for us. However, when MHFC gives away free seats to one category of members only it is somewhat ironical that it is the lowest-paying group of members that benefits, and there's no attempt to include higher-paying members in the offer. I have in fact contacted the club a couple of times on this, suggesting it try and find a solution to include all members, but to no avail; it's just in the "too hard" basket. It is particularly irksome because at nearly all matches except home derbies there are rows and rows of empty A and B seats, even though they are reserved for members who just don't turn up.

 

I believe one or two EPL clubs have a system by which a season-ticket holder who is not going to attend a particular match notifies the club and then that seat can be resold. I'd be happier if I sensed that MHFC was actually looking at the issue instead of just hiding behind the "reserved seat" mantra.

 

Individual issues like this are small in themselves. But collectively they contribute to the reasons why our club doesn't grow.

 

 

It's a tough one. I sit with my dad in B and we get there at different times. And I specifically get there at the last possible moment now, because there's this guy who sits near us (I wouldn't even have a clue which one is meant to be his seat), he's always flying solo and he just decides to sit next to whoever in my section gets there first and include himself in their conversations, talk to them during the game and whatever. He's harmless and he means well, but he's bloody annoying. And if I roll up before my dad, he'll come up and sit in my dad's seat and stay there, until dad comes along (even if that's after kick off, meaning he's getting up and moving around, blocking people's view while the game's going), when he'll sit in someone else's seat (not his own). Others would probably be fine with that, but it gets on my nerves when he comes and sits next to me, or when I get there and he's sitting in my seat. So I probably wouldn't be keen for some randoms to rock up and sit next to me.

 

I remember a couple of years ago, Heart had some promo regarding a free upgrade of your seat, like B to A and A to Ace of Hearts (or whatever it was called). One way it could work is to work it in conjunction with something like that, so you have an indication of which seats will be vacant and members that would prefer to can choose to bring a friend and sit in their usual area if they want.

 

As for the lineup: hoping Marino and Dugandzic are left off the squad.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Preview: City v Roar

 

Friday, 27 March 2015

 

By Iain Strachan 

 

 

Reigning A-League champions Brisbane Roar have fallen behind in the race for a top-six finish and face a crucial showdown away to direct rivals Melbourne City in the match of the round on Saturday night.

 

When: Saturday, 28 March 2015

Where: AAMI Park, Melbourne

Kick-Off: 7:30 PM (AEDT) 

 

 

BLUFFER'S GUIDE 

 

It could be now or never for title-holders Brisbane Roar if they want to defend their crown in the 2014-15 finals series. 

 

The Queensland side are five points behind sixth-placed Melbourne City and although they still have one game in hand on John van 't Schip's men, should they lose this one, it would take a major collapse from the incumbents over the final weeks of the campaign for the Roar to sneak back in. 

 

Brisbane's cause has not been helped by the international break. The champions are without Socceroos Matt McKay and Luke DeVere and Olyroos James Donachie and Corey Brown.  

 

With first-choice goalkeeper Michael Theo still injured and centre-back Jade North to miss Saturday's match with a groin problem, the visitors' backline will be paper thin at AAMI Park. 

 

On Wednesday Frans Thijssen used holding midfielder Luke Brattan in central defence at home to the Western Sydney Wanderers, who romped to a 4-1 win despite having not previously triumphed on the road this term. 

 

City will be licking their lips at the prospect of facing such a wounded animal, particularly given the hosts will get back three key forwards in Harry Novillo, David Williams and Josh Kennedy. 

 

Van 't Schip is also contending with a lengthy list of absentees - Connor Chapman is suspended, Damien Duff is out for the season, while Robbie Wielaert, Jacob Melling and Ben Garuccio are all injured. 

 

The international break has been less costly to City though, with mid-season Singaporean recruit Safuwan Baharudin and midfielder Aaron Mooy, with the Socceroos in Europe, the only missing personnel. 

 

OPTA DATA 

 

- Melbourne City have won three of their last four against Brisbane, losing the other. 

 

- The Roar have lost each of their last four away games against Melbourne City, failing to score in the last two. 

 

- None of the last eight games between these two has ended in a draw (five wins for City, three for Roar). 

 

- City are unbeaten in seven league matches at AAMI Park, a run which began with a win over the Roar (W5 D2). 

 

- John van 't Schip's side have conceded just three goals in that run of games and never more than once in any of those games. 

 

ROUTE TO GOAL

 

Van 't Schip started with Robert Koren, Mate Dugandzic and James Brown in attacking positions last time out.  

 

Will that trio keep their spots or could we see any of Williams, Kennedy and Novillo come back into the starting XI?  

 

Whichever combination the boss goes with, they will be expected to break down Brisbane's makeshift rearguard with relative ease. 

 

Given their weaknesses at the back, attack may be the best form of defence for the Roar.  

 

Matt McKay's energy in midfield will be missed, while they must also make do without Henrique's goals and the creativity of Thomas Broich.  

 

That leaves Jean Carlos Solorzano, Andrija Kaluderovic, Brandon Borrello and Dimitri Petratos to get the job done up front. 

 

WHO'S BEEN IN THE SPOTLIGHT THIS WEEK? 

 

James Brown's winner in the surprise 1-0 victory away to Sydney FC last Friday was his first goal since netting six times for Gold Coast United in 2011-12.  

Can he retain his place and hit the back of the net again this weekend? 

 

 

FORM LINES 

 

Melbourne City: WWLLW 

 

City have won three of their last five, beating Sydney 1-0 away, the Newcastle Jets 4-0 and Adelaide 3-1, both of those at home.  

 

Sandwiched in between were successive away defeats, 3-2 at Western Sydney and 1-0 at Central Coast, results which had threatened to derail their finals challenge. 

 

Brisbane Roar: LLLWD 

 

It's been a shocking run for the champions, who had lost their last three in succession, 4-1 at home to Western Sydney, 2-1 at home to Wellington Phoenix and 5-4 away to Sydney FC. That's 11 goals conceded in just three matches. 

 

DID YOU KNOW? 

 

Brisbane Roar have never kept a clean sheet away to Melbourne City (six games). 

 

PREDICTION

 

Melbourne City 3-1 Brisbane Roar 

 

They very rarely make life easy for themselves, but surely this weekend City can seize a golden opportunity to deal a hammer blow to the hopes of their weakened rivals. 

 

Fail to do so and familiar, pointed questions about the mentality of van 't Schip's men will asked yet again. 

 

http://www.a-league.com.au/article/preview-melbourne-city-fc-v-brisbane-roar-fc/pwumcbptejym1njk1n9lsumzo

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I don't see the defence changing, with 2 cleansheets over the past 2 games. So IMO the question is: what will the front 6 look like?

 

I'm betting we'll see:

 

                                 Novillo          Kennedy          Brown

 

                                             Koren          Germano

 

                                                       Paartalu 

 

 

I'm tipping Brown to get the nod to start after his match winner last week. But the likes of Williams, Dugandzic and Ramsay (in the best goal scoring form out of all forwards in recent games) will all be a good shout to be subbed on for Brown early in the 2nd half if Brown looks too anonymous and isn't influential.

 

Really big game for Koren. He'll be playing in his preferred no. 10 position, so a quiet game from him will be inexcusable. And with Mooy absent Koren has to really influence the game and be the creator in midfield. I'm actually pretty confident that Koren will thrive in midfield without Mooy. Both players to me seem to like getting on the ball a lot, so I can see Koren thriving by being able to be the main ball player in midfield in Mooy's absence (maybe in the future, with more games, they'll play better together. But I don't think there's really been a game where both Mooy and Koren have been in midfield, and both of them have played their very best football). We'll need Koren to step up tomorrow to help create chances for the newly fit forwards Kennedy and Novillo, and I can see Koren rising to the occasion. 

 

 

Brisbane getting a proper defender back in North is a last minute boost to them, but still I think they'll be too depleted and too tired (both physically and mentally) to be able to prevent a Melbourne City win. I'll be very keen though to see which of Melbourne City's 6 front players can give the team spark and show game changing ability tomorrow, because in the run in to the finals we need our attackers to be in form and impressing.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Weather perfect, big game, nothing else on it Melbourne tonight.

 

We should be fucking breaking five figures.

We would except the script we've been reading from for the last 5 seasons would say that we will choke with anxiety and either play a timid draw or a bad loss. Most casual and committed fans know how the Heart/City script repeatedly plays out and are understandably wary until there's clear evidence that we have changed. I'm not convinced myself although there have been a few encouraging signs we are still far too inconsistent. My tip is for a 0-0 draw or a 0-1 loss.

Crowd 7,000

I hope to be wrong.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Starting XI (@MelbourneCity) | Velaphi (GK), Clisby, Kisnorbo, Jaliens, Retre, Paartalu, Germano, Koren, Brown, Kennedy, Dugandzic #Final450

Subs (@MelbourneCity) | Redmayne, Ramsay, Murdocca, Novillo, Williams #Final450 #MCYvBRI

Decent bench but that starting lineup looks pretty awful, particularly the front 3...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I can only think that Novillo isn't 100% and that is why he is on the bench.

 

I hope Paartalu can show more this game as we don't need to be carrying passengers.

 

Personally I would have had Kennedy on the bench and played Brown as the centre forward and Williams on the right.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Williams starting? Lol which games have you been watching?

 

Niko the fact is Dugandzic, Williams and Kennedy have showed nothing in the last few games. If we had more to choose from then neither of them would make my starting line up. In addition JK has been struggling with injury and I believe it would have been better to ease him back in when the Brisbane players weren't as fresh.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'm finally up in time for a Melbourne City game again. For the last few weeks I've not been able to catch them, due to kick-off times (some of them while I've been at work, others at 4am), and due to being in New York.

 

And I managed to get online in just enough time to see the replays from the first goal... Good start, I just hope we can build on it. This match is the big one.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

 Share

×
×
  • Create New...