Leaderboard

I think the capo should control his language a bit. All l hear at the back is "fuck, fuck, fuck...."

Da na na na Chapman. ( Batman theme song)

A bit annoying this result after being 1-0 up with 30 minutes to go, but the result is pretty decent given that we were playing the league leaders, who going into the match had only lost 1 game in 11, and just smashed Central Coast 4-1 last round. The performance was also pretty strong. We had 11 shots to 6, and largely played the game in Perth's half having 52% possession and 60% territory. Was also pretty concerned going into the game, and thought the disruption to our defence, with Hoffman dropping out of the team less than 24hrs before kickoff, could unsettle things. But Wielaert came in and put in a respectable performance, making use of his passing skill and his skill on the ball. I think the slightly changed defence did as well as it did because Chapman has truly stabilised the defence. I'm starting to become convinced that he's the main factor explaining our defensive turnaround. He has a wonderful defensive presence, and is comfortable dribbling the ball into the middle third. Mooy continues to dazzle. His shooting has been solid this season IMO, and it's been bad luck as much as anything else that has prevented him from scoring more goals. Today his finishing was good again, and he took his goal very well. The concern with playing young players is that they are generally inconsistent, oscillating between impressive games and flat and weak games. But Melling is showing his qualities every game, in particular him playing and defending with fantastic energy. I thought Kisnorbo had a fairly off game. He completely lost Djulbic on the set piece taken shortly after Perth scored, and I'm not sure but he might have been meant to mark Garcia for Perth's goal as well. Also other details seemed off with his game. Ideally experienced players, and especially the captain, should be consistent, so hopefully Kisnorbo can consistently deliver performances similar to his Melbourne derby performance. I fully agree with the consensus; I think we need more attacking talent in our front 3rd, and in particular we could really use a reliable no 9. None of our front 3 are threatening goal often enough for my liking. Credit to Williams for providing an assist, something he doesn't do often enough IMO (I'm pretty certain he didn't provide 1 assist last season, despite playing several games in the no 10 position). But we simply need more from the front 3, and I get the impression that our stellar midfield saves our forwards' blushes a bit. All up, will take the point. Something we can build on. Now we're heading into 2 winnable games with the team in good form, and have the likes of Duff and Koren returning to the team.

Kisnorbo cost us 2 points today and almost cost us all 3. Shit marking and takes cunts on for no reason. Also tries to play miracle balls through midfield. Should be banned from passing to anyone but the fullback or a midfielder.

Ange you unless fat greek cunt

So the only logical conclusion we can make from all this is that Kalmar just didn't want to live in Newcastle. Can't blame him.

going backwards with chants like 'knick-knack paddy whack' when there's an enormous selection of better, simpler and louder chants available on this forum

Koren should be coming on for Ramsay and being given a free role to roam inside from the left. Ramsay offers absolutely nothing in attack bar a few awkward step overs.

Shoutout to Robbie weilart. Played out of position today, had a bit of trouble going forward because he has the speed of a three legged horse, but I thought he was really good today. desperately, desperately need a striker, just have no one to kick the ball to whenever we get the ball forward. If the point of the game was to pass the ball aimlessly around the edge of the box, we'd be league leaders. also think that kisnorbo had a really bad game, nearly cost us 2-3 goals tonight due to sloppy play or not marking his man properly, needs a kick up the ass for the next game.

@RichGarcia19: For all those not happy with me celebrating my goal.... I never played for @MelbourneCity I played for melbourne heart...

Ned Zelic has deadset lost the plot (if he knew where it was to begin with). 'Commentator' not 'special' commentator means you can follow the play once in a while instead of providing a furiously expressed opinion about Perth not getting a penalty and then subsequently Garcia being pulled up for dissent, and several incoherent points in between (individual brilliance).

Ramsey is good in space but as soon as someone in within a meter he packs his dacks and has no ideas what he's doing

Wieleart named at RB on the Facebook page. Predicting 8-0 Perth.

Thanks for the memories!

Yeh you have nick kalmar and we'll have Aaron mooy. Good trade

Pretty sure it's just the playing fields receiving a make over.

i told off kids tonight, tried to get them to join in and just looked at me and basically told me to fuck off, went over to them and told them, you have an active membership, you are expected to sing and especially being at the front, you will make the terrace look bad. they ended up just giving me lip and i walked away before i did something stupid. when we went to sit down for we love, i made sure to have a go at them for sitting down and joining in now and not before, told them to stand up if they dont want to participate. all these new members who think they have a right to sit there and do nothing just because they have an active membership, they need to be kicked to the sides and leave the main bay with the people who are committed to the cause.

Goal Weekly always take photos from the game, you could contact them and see if you are able to purchase some. These are off thier Facebook page ( Or try FourFourTwo

Please get rid of the 'And it's Melbourne City, Melbourne City FC....' chant. It sounds shit in the epl when Arsenal, Chelsea etc sing it but is a million times worse over here. No one likes it

Yes playing Duff on the right is utter stupidity. He has no plan for how he will fit Koren in his team and so takes off Melling. The guy is a youth coach and thats it.

Just a request. Lacking any I.T skills I was hoping someone could post the start of yesterday's game. My little bloke walked out with the teams and I didn't get any good pics. Much appreciated.

He needs to use the next couple of games to get some match time into him and get accustomed to the league. He's traveling below 50% at the moment. The break may be coming at a bad time for him. What it does though is give him an idea if the league and time to really train with the team and get used to the system. Watched a lot of him and the guy is a top liner. Just needs to play and he will be a star in this league.

Both were named by my source. Considering Tando's a bit of a journeyman n Redders is at his 2nd club, do you think we'd be looking for someone outside of the A-League?

Ognenovski plays = best defence in the league. Ognenovski injured = conceed 3 goals. It's actually why I put my money on Adelaide, Sydney are fucked without OG Too bad he is probably done for good after that injury.

I edited my post above to explain, basically playing with 3 in defence we will need to get rid of one of our midfielders rather than adding one, as you'd still need Hoffman and Garuccio out wide, albeit in a more attacking role, but you'd need to add another central defender at the expense of one of the midfielders.

That's not how playing with 3 in defence works. A formation like this would never work and would never be tried. Playing with 3 in defence is usually more like playing with 5 in defence, or at the very least there would be 3 defenders playing centrally and 2 players from out wide playing quite defensively, whether they're wingbacks or wide midfielders. You can't play it with 1 central defender and 2 wide defenders (like your formation seems to suggest since Garuccio is there), hoping the DM fills the gap centrally. Teams would just play the ball through the centre and score easily. Or if you're suggesting those 3 defenders would all be fairly central, than the wide players are too far up and too attacking (Duff and Dugandzic)

If I had to skol a drink every time Arnold said "you can't make excuses" in that interview (followed by doing just that) I'd be hammered right now.

I guess if JVS isn't given any leeway with players missing then surely Arnold shouldn't either. A perfect opportunity for Arnold to showcase his managerial skills with some of his players missing from the squad.

totally agree- he has been great in the last 3 games. Breaking up play, and winning headers in defence and getting the ball to feet and playing simple one/two touch stuff when we have the ball. Exactly what we need from him with Mooy/Koren in the side.

Chapman is the real deal. He has transformed not only our defence, but our entire team in the 3 games he has played. He is so sharp across the ground, and reads the play fantastically. He also puts in 100%, loves a strong challenge and gave Williams a bollocking today for not making a run when he should have. Teams are also having to adjust to the threat of him carrying the ball into midfield, when they drop off too deep. If he keeps going like this we'll find it very very difficult to keep him come seasons end. Socceroos CB at the next World Cup for mine. Maybe i'm getting carried away, but f&*k me he is brilliant!

we really lack forwards. Ramsay, Williams and Dugandzic clearly not up to it. It's evident when most of our goals this season have come from midfielders and even defenders. Hopefully Kennedy will help fix that area, and even Duff when he's playing regularly again. Defensively we look a lot better with chapman in the centre, but if we're to have a serious squad we need quality fullbacks on either side. Velaphi was decent today, didn't do much wrong. The goal was from Kisnorno leaving Garicia completely unmarked.

Well I think 1-1 against the top side is a decent result we could have easily won and have apart from the goal Perth didn't create much. If we play like that against Newcastle and Central Coast we should win easily.

Were you watching number 6 Ange you stooge

Of all the cunts to equalize!

Well in! Great goal

I hate the cunt but it should have been a penalty There was contact because Garcia left his leg dangling behind him in an attempt to milk the penalty Kisnorbo took the bait. Penalty Well thank the lord for Alan Milliner then

Should be an entertaining game. Things I'll be looking out for: - Can the team continue to keep up the high intensity and high concentration levels for 90 minutes? - The team has won the past 2 games despite not scoring in the 1st half. I reckon if the team can go up in the first half, and perform as well as it has been over the past 2 matches, then the team has real good chances of getting a good result - Can the front 3 threaten goal more? - What difference does the Koren factor make? Perfect day for a game. Pumped up for some good football.

i miss ontheball

hope he does well at WSW. I think popovic will get him into good condition, so it's a much better move than going to Newcastle. Wish him all the best

I still think if we're going to keep it we need to make a recording that is shorter and slower.

Can't believe Dhoni is India's captain. Terrible captain, 2nd rate keeper and a flat track bully batsman. Kohli would be a much better choice.

Well let's see what they've built in secret. If it is a decent facility then I will be impressed. Sidwell era I'd expect this story to equate to throwing some grass seeds on a paddock and bunging a few atcos down as the offices.

“It's built on the same model as Manchester. It's a much smaller site, obviously, but because we invested so much time and effort in Manchester in developing the actual model for what an ideal training campus should look like, it is that in miniature without losing anything in scale."

TTDIM: Cards Against Humanity

Happy birthday Jesus

Did you even read my post? What are you talking about a .............. "How are your examples of EPL players and A-League International Marquees at all relevant???" If you read it, my post focuses on players who are playing for clubs while their families reside in another area. Of interest Josh Kennedy was playing in Japan while his wife and kids were here in Australia. Players all over the world have to leave their family in one town/city/country to play elsewhere. Even Posh Spice didn't move to Paris. Is Newcastle a bad club? It must have been after it gave Mark Milligan his first taste, and of late Brilliante, Tagart, Goodwin .................. Bad Club?????? - Maybe a bad Post. You can always look back on a life that was - but you can never look back on a life that could-have been. To me, he will only be remembers for that one goal against Newcastle on a suburban football pitch. If he chose family over a revived a-league career then he will regret this decision for the rest of his life. Comparing David beckhams predicament to nick kalmar. Fmd

There was never any pepper spray in the terrace when we were in red n white.

SHT is perfect

How is Hey Jude more intimidating than Happy Together? Furthermore, how does Hey Jude reflect our football team? No 'hate' but you don't think it's working and it's 'laughable'? That sounds like hatred to me This makes no sense and the thing is I (don't) know what you're talking about.