Jump to content
Melbourne Football
Caddy

Week 20: Melbourne v Gold Coast United - Feb 17 - 8pm

Recommended Posts

Luke    488

Bolton

Marrone Good Hamill Goodwin

Germano Colosimo Fred

Wiliams Maycon Terra

Good and Hamil cost us at least a goal every week without fail and I've had a gut full

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Attila    85

--------------- Bolton-----------------

---Marrone---Hamill---Goodwin---

-------------Germano----------------

--------Shroj--Fred--Sarkies-------

------------- Patterson---------------

----------Terra---Babalj--------------

Subs: Mattei, Good, Worm, Walker

Let me justify my choices:

We are playing the worst team in the league and we need something to change in order to reignite something in squad. Drop Maycon, Colosimo and Williams from the last game and elevate NYL players Patterson and Walker to see what they can add as they are both good at what they do. Patterson is a bit smaller but plays with passion and has a driven sort of mentality on the pitch, while Walker is someone who can come off the bench for either Babalj or Terra and take his chances. Goodwin keeps his spot in the team plays well with two wing backs who can move forward.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

.........................BOLTON...............................

MARRONE HAMMILL COLOSSIMO GOODWIN

........................GERMANO.............................

............FRED.................. SARKIES..............

WALKER..........BABALJ.....WILLIAMS

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
11v11    6

Next week is a must win obviously. But if we do win we are still in the 6. Some top teams to play after that. We should have Mate, Jason and Aziz back and the run then could be different. But yesterday there seemed to be no passion or atmosphere within the team. Worm's first touch was terrible, and Eli looks down on confidence, still trying to push through the packs. Some horrible turn overs by some players. Goodwin made runs but did not get much service, he held his own in his second game. Sydney winning did us no favours on the table regarding points. No team can afford to drop points now. Can't get much tighter on the table. The coaching staff have a big job to do this week revving the boys up for Gold Coast. Also some selection issues to motivate the lads. I thiink maybe another youth team member at least on the bench. Maybe Zac Walker to get some time up front. We need some raw passion to inspire the team.

The club needs passionate supporters in the bad times not just the good. Get along next week and rev them up. There is still a finals berth up for grabs.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Caddy    195

Good is suspended so don't include him in your hypothetical teams...

In - Fred, Z Walker / Zahra, Sarkies

Out - Maycon, Good, Worm

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
11v11    6

Good is suspended so don't include him in your hypothetical teams...

In - Fred, Z Walker / Zahra, Sarkies

Out - Maycon, Good, Worm

Hopefully Zahra/Walker can turn it on today in the youth game against fagelaide. Give them a go next week. But @caddy I agree with your ins and outs. When Behich gets back I would like to see Goodwin on the left wing. Both those playrs would make a good attacking pair. Then Duganzic and Marrone on the right. Cannot wait to see Fred back we need him badly. Maybe Terra on the bench as Fred backup.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Caddy    195

I think Hamill is a better choice than Good anyway at CB.

Agree, Good's second yellow was ridiculous by him anyway, it's like he wanted a week off. He needs a rest.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Hammerhead    212

Back to basics after last weeks performance. Nothing flashy. Grind it out for a win.

............................BOLTON...............................

MARRONE HAMMILL COLOSSIMO GOODWIN

GERMANO.......FRED.....RIED.............SARKIES

...................BABALJ............TERRA...................

BENCH: MATTEI - SHROJ - WORM - WALKER

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Ando    2,125

I don't think Zahra is quite ready yet. He was lively today in the NYL match, but still isn't 100% there I'd say.

Look at giving Z. Walker a spot, and Patterson can't be too far away. Maycon in all fairness needs to be halfway to Brazil come Friday night, so promoting a bit of youth might not be a bad thing.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Woody    642

All for giving youth games.

Sick of lethargic and disinterested players.

Has to change this week. It has to.

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
perthheart    686

Agree it's time for some more youth to be given a go. We need a win desperately this week. We win and some confidence will return in time for Mate, Hoff and Behich's return. Is the kind of thing that could re ignite our season.

Bolton

Marronne Hamill Colosimo Goodwin

Germano

Paterson Fred

Williams Babalj Terra

Subs: Mattei, Shroj, Reid, Walker

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Cammo    34

The Age suggests we will play Fred and work hard to get Thompson ready to go too.

I'm all for bringing in a NYL player or two. Maycon just isn't up to it unfortunately.

Edited by Cammo

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
cadete    6,062

The Age suggests we will play Fred and work hard to get Thompson ready to go too.

I'm all for bringing in a NYL player or two. Maycon just isn't up to it unfortunately.

The annoying thing is that of course Zac should get that bench Striker spot – but we all know that it will go to Maycon.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Caddy    195

Just saw Thwaite will be missing for the GC. They have probably twice as many injuries as us, absolutely no excuses not to get 3 points. The boys should have fire in their bellies.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
cadete    6,062

I echo the feeling of those above, we cannot get a game that will be any easier to win and in the current circumstances thank Ghod it has come now.

I feel for the other Roosters if they have to be stand next me when the whistle goes this time and we have Lost/Drawn this game.

But we wont - Because "All you need is Fred!" :)

Edited by cadete

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
dRoy    572

Lol at people saying they aren't going.

I'll be there. I don't really care if we win or lose. Of course I'd love to win. this year has been a massive learning curve for me. I just like being at the Impy and the terraces, hanging around with really great people, having a great time etc.

MHFC!

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Pandev    82

I don't think Zahra is quite ready yet. He was lively today in the NYL match, but still isn't 100% there I'd say.

Look at giving Z. Walker a spot, and Patterson can't be too far away. Maycon in all fairness needs to be halfway to Brazil come Friday night, so promoting a bit of youth might not be a bad thing.

Anyone know how Fred performed in the youth team?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
jw1739    6,886

He had a run, did not push himself and come off after exactly 30 minutes.

...and immediately put an ice-pack on his left groin area. I doubt that he will play against GCU. Why risk it? If we can't beat them without Fred then quite frankly we don't deserve to. Taseski is probably fitter, and we have Patterson and Blumgart from the youth team. If we just keep bringing Fred back too early we will get nothing out of him for the next two years either. He may be another Aloisi - someone we don't try to play every game. Each player needs to be managed as an individual.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Torn Asunder    1,307

...and immediately put an ice-pack on his left groin area. I doubt that he will play against GCU. Why risk it? If we can't beat them without Fred then quite frankly we don't deserve to. Taseski is probably fitter, and we have Patterson and Blumgart from the youth team. If we just keep bringing Fred back too early we will get nothing out of him for the next two years either. He may be another Aloisi - someone we don't try to play every game. Each player needs to be managed as an individual.

He did look a little proppy as he came off and he kept the groin iced till just before half time.... but he was all smiles (as usual). My thoughts are that he still did not look 100%

Edited by Torn Asunder

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
downbylaw    50

At least he made it thru 30min, those type of injuries can be expected to happen generally within 20min of exercise.

We all have to remember he isn't 20years old so its a slow come back.

Its all ready a concern but if it goes again it becomes very worrying indeed.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

×