Jump to content
Melbourne Football

moops

Members
  • Posts

    2,471
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    15

Posts posted by moops

  1. 2 hours ago, D.B. Cooper said:

    Indeed.

    My impression is that it is easier for a teenager to start in the Premier League than in the A League. Now as to why that would be I’ve no idea, but it seems to be a difficult environment for younger players to get a chance.

    It may have to do with the wage cap, there is a minimum spend?

    CCM are the benchmark obviously, they had a rough period, but they keep churning out the yoof and they sold players nearly equal to us last year.

  2. 24 minutes ago, jw1739 said:

    Indeed, it is that kind of season. But this is where the club has to dig deep and needs to have the Academy with players ready to step up. If you follow the EPL you'll see how Liverpool (and I'm no fan!) have just had to do that, and the teenagers stood up and did the club proud.

    Maybe we do but there is a reluctance to play them?

    Politidis looks good when he comes on, Caputo can't get a sniff even with Macca off form, Hall is 25 and should be released, but he just hasn't had any time at all in the last 4 years and then there's yoof we let go who are carving it up for other teams.

    • Like 1
  3. 13 hours ago, Torn Asunder said:

    He has our team set up terribly. Way too much space between our midfield and forwards, especially when  we lose the ball up front. Once we've lost the ball up forward the opponent easily plays to the next line, normally centrally. 

    When we went to a back 3 last night (which I'm convinced was an idea from the assistant coach), with Arslan dropping deeper, and the extra man then in the midfield we actually controlled the game and attacked with meaning, and really on any other night would have at least scored one

    The same old setup, with players not good to enough to execute effectively means we are so predictable it's not funny.

    It was obvious after bout 15 minutes last night that we'd lose, via some cheap goals ... and yep, that happened.  I feel for JMac. His slump can be blamed on the team as he gets next to zero service, and his confidence is absolutely shot. It's happening with all our forwards. 

    No doubt in my mind, a better coach would have us winning more than we're losing.

    Trust me. The team is strong enough, it's our style of play and management that's killing us.

    Time to fuck off Vidmar. Go back to Adelaide and take your recruitment mate with ya. Club needs some fresh blood. Complacency has crept in.  Other clubs are showing us how to do it and are going past us. This shouldn't happen

     

     

    Agree, also having our wide players on the opposite side the ball is being played are inside the halfway line, maybe due to the space. There's barely a press, we look static.

    I doubt Vidmar will be let go, same as Petrillo. Vidmar hasn't earned the right to continue though and Petrillo got this seasons recruiting all wrong, but he usually get's it so we are at least competitive, should he be let go?

  4. 19 hours ago, Zanty said:

    everyone saying "Time to go" hahahah

    Nothing changes this season whoever comes in might as well just keep him and play the likes of Caputo, Lopane, Politidis

    Lopane is growing on me, I just think he is being utilised wrong and it's not helping him and can be frustrating to watch at times.

  5. Sydney is starting to hit their straps, they looked impressive last night and were enjoyable to watch.

    I'm starting to feel sorry for that bloke that put money on us getting in the 6, it may not happen. We have a run of home games which we need to win, but our form is on par with the Jets atm.

    • Like 1
  6. 1 hour ago, Mr MO said:

    The win ratio seems to be being brought down by the Heart days if you look Australia. Not fully clear in such an overview.

    E7204B1C-3830-4670-890D-7A8CE9AF5C91.png

    Which exemplifies what I am saying, we were chucking ice in bins for ice baths as Heart, we didn't overperform at all.

    Chivas he did better as they are one of the better teams in the MX League.

    Twente he probably underperformed.

    Maybe it's adaptability, if you have lots of resources you can bring in players to suit what you want, but if not you have to be more adaptable with what you have, which suits a salary capped league as well imho.

  7. 24 minutes ago, Mr MO said:

    How many of the 144 games did JVS coach under heart?

    All but one season iirc.

    If you look at his history on transfermarkt, he has been pretty poor until Greece and now Ajax. It seems he can do ok if he has access to top players for the level, but won't get poor teams playing above themselves.

    I think that's the kind of coach we need, like Montgomery for CCM, Italiano for Nix. I don't care if they are from the EPL, NPL or the Fiji tbh. If a coach can show they can get a small or middling team to punch above their weight, they have to have something about them.

    • Like 1
    • Thanks 1
  8. 1 hour ago, NewConvert said:

    I am not sure how you can say that. Does the club publish figures on backroom expenditure?

    In any case, all clubs in all sports are confronted with the same issue: how do you find the best coach for the team? How do you build a quality backroom that is able to remain fresh? If you look at Spurs over the last five years they spent big on managers but no silverware. Managerial brand names came and went. Opposite to that, is how did Wellington find Italiano? CCM found Mark Jackson?

    True, there's probably a diamond in the NPL who hasn't got his chance yet.

  9. 7 hours ago, kingofhearts said:

     

    I never understood about this club how we invest all this money into the squad and then spend the least amount of money possible on the coach. 

    In a salary cap league it makes the most impact to spend the most on the backroom imho, also developing players to sell on, more to spend on the marque.

    That we didn't have a GK coach for a while is pretty poor.

  10. 57 minutes ago, Mr MO said:

    What makes you think there is nobody else available?

    People calling for PK have completely forgotten or are ignoring under what circumstances the succes was achieved. Besides there is some concerning proof on the table now about his capabilities. No PK would do better this squad.

    Agree, I'm also not a fan of returning managers, it never works out for whatever reason.

    • Like 3
  11. 3 minutes ago, MHFC-FAN said:

    Jmac in the worst form of his career, yet keeps starting...even Tilio could have had an easy through ball to Jamie but instead took the harder option and went for goal himself. I don't think Jamie even joined in that goal celebration, something definitely is going on with him and the team...

    If rumours are true he wants out probably, just going through the motions.

  12. 5 minutes ago, belaguttman said:

    We seem to be under instructions to sit deep, not press at all, and leave the wide spaces for Sydney players to do what they want with no pressure at all 

    I'm seeing it pretty similar as well, Tilio is pressing and Leckie usually ends up following, otherwise nada.

    We certainly seem to want to compress the midfield.

    3 minutes ago, haz said:

    I'm liking the Chilean. 

    He looks great.

×
×
  • Create New...