Jump to content
Melbourne Football

IssySG

Members
  • Posts

    651
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    21

Posts posted by IssySG

  1. Idk what our actual plans are, but feel like we need a new, long term CB in the january transfer market. With an average age of 32, all three of our regular CB's are liable to be injured at any given point, seems like a recipe for disaster. You can't trust Nuno, I love Curtis Good but at the moment he's a shadow of his former self, and Souprayen is Souprayen. I know we have Jordon Hall, but I feel like if there was every any real chance of him breaking into the team, it'd have happened by now.

    Do your thing Petrillo

    • Like 1
  2. 43 bucks for a ticket is a joke. I think the club is trying to cash in on the strong contingent of away fans each ACL team has brought over. What makes it worse, is that the only Melbourne City supporters who would be buying tickets for this are ones without memberships, so when you get a chance to potentially re-engage them with the club, theres every chance they (fairly) sod it off due to the cost.

    Do better City.

  3. 4 minutes ago, MHFC-FAN said:

    What rocks have you been smoking lately? He may have made some mistakes, but he's far from the worst keeper we've had. If we had a better back 4 in front of him he would hardly be getting noticed...

    Give me a spell. He's fine, and that is the most generous description I could give him. He's long past his best, and I think you could make an argue for the last three seasons his decline has been pretty rapid. 

    Like I've said on his forum before, while the club is going through a squad transition, I'd rather be putting this games into a young promising keeper i.e. Beach. Jamie Young might have been okay for a stop gap if we were in the hunt for trophies, but that clearly isn't the case. So my argument is really what's to be gained from playing him? He isn't saving us enough points to win anything, and when his contract is up, what then? Invest in young Australian goalkeepers - this club has done pretty well in the last half decade backing young Australian players and that for me was a point of pride.

    • Like 2
  4. 1 hour ago, NewConvert said:

    Simply because he is a GK? If manifesting resulted in the termination of contracts then there would hardly be enough players to have a two team competition given the number of tactical fouls that occur every match. And in any case, the player can claim that has he was not red-carded due process was followed (albeit AFAIK this has not been tested in a court of law).

    Mate, I was just joshing. I simply want Jamie Young out of my club, is that too much to ask? 😭

    • Like 1
  5. 18 minutes ago, jw1739 said:

    One that stands out like dogs balls is that we need better goalkeepers in our squad that the likes of Glover and Young.

    Maybe a hot take? But I think Glover was largely pretty decent for us. To me, goalkeeprs fall into trap more so than any other position that they can do ten good things in a game, one bad and people tend to only remember the bad. He started almost every game for the Austrlian U 23 teams, and when he was at City and playing regularly he was making Socceroos squads. Theres a reason he earnt himself a move to a decently sized championship club. 

    And even if he wasn't perfect, there was obvious upside of him being a promising young australian keeper. With Jamie, hes obviously well past it, so whats to be gained from playing him? Might not be for everyone, but I'd personally rather start Beach every game and work through the teething pains - especially when we as a club are in a transitioning period.

  6. 24 minutes ago, belaguttman said:

    Let them enjoy their brief moment in the sun

    Hope they enjoyed watching Connor Metcalfe and Jordan Bos putting on an exhibition and Jamie Maclaren bagging a hat trick from the bench.

    One team in Melbourne.

    • Like 1
×
×
  • Create New...