Jump to content
Melbourne Football

Jacques Le Cube

Members
  • Posts

    249
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    1

Posts posted by Jacques Le Cube

  1. Every time I have seen the visitors play this year they have been woeful. They leave so much space in the middle of the park for the opposition to play.

    I was really worried that they would rally for this game and turn it into a shit fight (being a derby and they have a lot of players who like a scrap).

    So they have now lost 2 Melbourne derbies in 2 weeks and have their old rivals Adelaide next weekend! Shit time to be a visitor fan!

  2. On 13/01/2021 at 2:18 PM, Harrison said:

    Well said. I vividly remember watching the Denmark game and talking him up when he came on. He looked quite good, created a few chances or half-chances, and I thought he would easily make it in a big 5 European league. The injury was an awful one, and he just hasn’t got the game time since coming back. 

    I have always thought that our young Australian players shouldn’t head off until they’ve played in the A-League for a few seasons. Two or three at the very least, especially if they’re still in their teenage years or early twenties. When they’ve stood out and dominated consistently, then they’re probably ready. Our league is a good, solid standard and it’s a proper test for any young player. Yes they will have to adjust to the technical standards and the speed of the game overseas, but that’s not beyond them with the academies and curriculum we have down here now. But they have to be patient and they have to earn it. 

    I think its different for every player. A lot of our best players left Australia as teenagers without playing any senior Aleague/NSL football: Kewell, Cahill, Moore, Skoko, Neill,  etc. many others left for Europe after only playing 1 season and not establishing themselves.

    I think he was ready to move to Europe, he was taking the piss in the A League. He was on another level completely - He made his contemporaries like McGree look ordinary. And at the WC he clearly outperformed Kruse, Rogic and Leckie.

    The poor guy lost almost 2 full seasons to injury at Celtic. At Utrecht he is completing for a first team place with Eljero Elia and they had a coaching change in November. Utrecht was an odd choice of club because they traditionally play a disciplined, physical, blue-collar style of football. I doubt City currently care about his development since he will probably move for a free when his contract expires in June.

    If he stays injury free he will have an impact in Europe and for the Socceroos. He can do things on the field that no other Australian has been able to do for a long, long time.

  3. 31 minutes ago, jw1739 said:

    IMO you're looking at it from the wrong angle. They could get more fans to watch the men's senior team simply by signing a "big name" player. It's not about an instant increase in membership or an instant increase in fans at the Southern End. What they're are doing is trying to sew up a big catchment area for City Football Group and be the focus and identity of football across a big region of the city. Right from when the children are 7-8 years old.

    Like a 7-8 year old kid would care where their team trains.

     

    If where a team trains has such an significant affect on the local population and a clubs identity/supporter base, why don't we have tens of thousands of fans based in and around Bundoora? The club has been based there continuously for over a decade now.

     

    • Like 1
  4. Good player. I am surprised that he chose to stay in the A League. He has already proven himself to be one of the better local players in the League and has several years of first team football under his belt.

    I thought he would test himself at a higher level.

  5. 34 minutes ago, jw1739 said:

    Farce. Farce. Farce.

    I'm thinking City would have preferred to remain in Victoria, not because of Victoria as such but because we have our own training and administrative HQ under our full control, whereas the other two clubs do not.

    Petrillo was interviewed Tuesday morning on SEN. Its worth a listen to hear how it unfolded. City had accommodation and a training and a training base organised in Canberra. All 3 Vic teams were due to fly out Tuesday morning but the FFA brought it forward to Monday evening to try to beat the border closure.

     

    https://player.whooshkaa.com/episode?id=691509

     

    I have a bit of sympathy for the FFA on this one. The other codes managed not to mess up but the other codes don't have 70% of staff currently stood down. It appears in the AFL and NRL that the clubs were more responsible for getting themselves out of Melbourne whereas the FFA seemed to do everything.

     

  6. 10 minutes ago, Harrison said:

    Johnson has done well.

     

    10 minutes ago, Harrison said:

    All things considered a good deal.

    A good deal? TV revenue has dropped 81% from $171m to $32m. Also keep in mind there is a new team and an extra 27 games next season.

    As was reported, Fox wanted to reduce the $57m x 3 years to $11m x 3 years. At $32m, Fox are now paying exactly what they wanted in their initial low-ball offer and have engineered a face saving exit. Also, in shortening the contract length by 2 years Fox have saved ~$13m in production costs. (It costs Fox $40k to produce a game).

     

    But you wouldn't know it from the reporting of the new TV deal. Instead we get the headline: "A-League set for winter switch after securing new Fox Sports deal"

    Of course, the winter switch is not confirmed. It MAY happen, but there is no commitment. But that hasn't stopped Johnson from spruiking its potential:

     

    "The deal will see the professional game – for women and men – reactivated, and ensures that football is at the heart of all our thinking in the future"

    "The shift in the timing of the next A-League season is a strategic decision to enhance the alignment of our top tier professional men’s league "

    "better aligning the competition pyramid of Australian football to facilitate enhanced football outcomes"

     

    Just more jargon and spin to distract from the $139m the game has now lost.

     

  7. TTIM: The prevailing attitude within the football community that Streaming/P&R/National 2nd Division/Allowing A League transfers will fix football in this country when none of it will solve the fundamental problems.

    The Socceroos and A League have lost naming rights sponsors, A League clubs are losing millions, 70% of FFA staff have been stood down, we have no TV deal for a comp that starts in under a month and its all happening against the backdrop of a looming recession. Not to mention the dodgy new expansion teams who are hemorrhaging staff and are both being sued by former employees.

    This is a Doomsday scenario playing out before us. You would there would be more written about this but half the football media in this Country have lost their jobs. And when someone does write about it (ie Lucy Zelic last Friday), the FFA release several stories talking about how they are open to, yes you guessed it, Streaming/P&R/National 2nd Division/Allowing A League transfers. And somehow it manages to distract the masses with its management jargon and lack of commitment to anything.

    Lucy's article Re the foxtel standoff (12th of June): https://theworldgame.sbs.com.au/what-is-our-game-worth-the-bitter-stand-off-between-foxtel-and-ffa-heats-up

    Nikou open to 2nd Div (12th of June) https://theworldgame.sbs.com.au/second-division-still-our-ambition-says-ffa-chairman-nikou

    Johnson open to domestic transfers (14th of June) https://www.theage.com.au/sport/soccer/ffa-keen-to-establish-domestic-player-transfer-system-20200613-p55297.html

     

     

     

     

     

    • Like 1
  8. If Simon Cox doesn't fire, the Wanderers are in a world of pain. Still relying on Yeboah and Duke to score.

    Their best academy products are playing at other clubs (Devlin, Silvera). Also, Babel said at the start of the season that Baccus is their only young player with talent. He wasn't excited by any players in the youth team.

     

  9. It is all very amusing to watch this unfold.

    I wonder if the Visitors hierarchy are surprised that removing Kurz didn't instantly make Kamsoba and Athiu competent A-League level players.

    I also wonder when the heat will come on Paul Trimboli for signing so many below standard players to multi year deals.

    • Like 2
  10. Ladder

    1) Sydney

    2) Perth

    3) Visitors

    4) City

    5)WSW

    6)Western United

    7) Adelaide

    8 ) CCM

    9) Brisbane

    10) Newcastle

    11) Phoenix

    Champion: Sydney

    Golden Boot: Bruno Fornaroli

    First coach to be sacked: Merrick

    Bold prediction: The new, skillful generation of young local players like Metcalfe, McGree, Pasquali, Silvera etc will take the league by storm and make the previous generation of local players look very ordinary. It will end the merry-go-round of mediocre players who keep getting opportunities from conservative clubs unwilling to take a punt on talented youth and NPL players.

    City season: Score more, concede a few more. Noone will do well, Bart will be missed

  11. 4 hours ago, cadete said:

    It drives me nuts... and TBH its probably the best indicator of the quality of the league and its engagement with the Public.

    The player movement around the same league is something that belongs in a Semi-Professional League, where players want to stay in the local area but can still earn decent playing wages so they move from one local club to another on two year contracts when teams save up money to win a flag.

    This does not belong at the highest tier... the rules of the A-League are reminiscent of Command Economics and they have ultimately yielded the same results in having some very obvious built in flaws. Things like the Salary Cap, Player quotas only work if you own the game like AFL, NBA and NFL they dont when your one of many participants.

    It drives me nuts too but I don't believe it due to the model of the A-League, I think its the majority of blame lies with the clubs. Constantly changing owners, football philosophies and coaches because they don't know what they want to be.

    I could use any club as an example but I will use Adelaide. They spent 4 years under ex-Barcelona coaches, implementing a distinct style of play and philosophy and won all 3 domestic trophies. Then they changed tack completely and appointed Kurz who turned them in to a super disciplined counter attacking team that gave limited opportunities to youngsters. Then ownership changed (now 75% Dutch and 25% Chinese owned) and the new chairman , Piet Van de Pol, has appointed a fellow Dutchman and aims to turn the club into a developer of youth.

    WSW pulled the same shit, trying to replace Popovic with Gombau (whose philosophies and football are polar opposites) and we've seen it with JVS replaced by Joyce replaced by Mombaerts. Every new coach sees the game differently and rebuilds the squad with players capable of playing their style of football.

    I argue its the high turnover in A-League coaches that leads to the high turnover of A-league players.

    • Like 3
  12. 28 minutes ago, jw1739 said:

    And then back to the 2. Bundesliga.

    Kurz won the 2. Bundesliga with Kaiserslautern. The following season he guided them to 7th in the Bundesliga. That's a massive achievement.

    Kaiserslautern has only been in the Bundesliga for 2 of the last 12 seasons (both with Kurz in charge) and are now in the German 3rd division.

    6 hours ago, citypool said:

    Any ideas who could be shortlisted?

    I would guess Kurz, A. Vidmar, Kisnorbo and maybe Scott Miller.

    • Thanks 1
  13. 1 hour ago, bt50 said:

    Yes. He signed as a 27 year old though.

    I get where you are trying to come from here, but i reckon if you ran an age profile of visas over the years, a large % would be 30 +. Given players in the 22-28 range are generally at their peak and command the highest wages, thats the main reason. The alternative is to look to the younger end of the pool.

    That would be some very interesting data.

    Amongst others Broich, Berisha, isaias, carrusca, adlung, bort, buijs, Fred, Hernandez, Keogh, Brandan, bonevacia, Cassio, Kurto, Henrique, Flores, van Dijk, Novillo and Germano all joined the league in their 20s.

  14. 5 hours ago, bt50 said:

    Yeh i think that was what we were trying to do with Harrison; get talented youngsters some first team football and make ourselves a genuine option for young loanees. We're a far more attractive proposition to fans when its one of Europe's budding stars

    I don’t mind the theory, but Harrison is not one of “Europe’s budding stars”. I wouldn’t even call him a talented youngster.

    McGree, Wales, Atkinson, Genreau and Pierias are all younger than Harrison and I believe are they are already better footballers.

    There is no point to signing visa players who are inferior to local players.

    • Like 1
  15. On 31/03/2019 at 0:28 PM, Mr MO said:

    Yup, imagine last season not having Arzani then we there wouldn't have been many Joyce doubters at the start of the season.

    Or you could look at it another way: if it wasn’t for Joyce, we could have had a front 3 of Brandan/Bruno/ Arzani last season. With Kilkenny in the middle and Cahill coming off the bench.

    Oh what should’ve been.

    • Like 6
×
×
  • Create New...